Friday, December 09, 2005

Deborah Davis not to be charged

In the column of "See the ACLU does some good".....

Deborah Davis learned yesterday that she was not going to be prosecuted for refusing to show her id on a bus. For those who did not follow the earlier stories concerning this, the brief facts on this case:

via Dennis Roddy:

Our scene shifts to Denver, where Deborah Davis, 50, is in a bit of a pickle because she refused to show her ID to security guards who boarded the Regional Transportation District Bus 100 on her morning ride to work. The bus crosses through the Federal Center, a sprawling installation of government buildings. Signs there declare that anyone entering must show valid, government-issued identification. They are considerably smaller than the large banners reading "Public Welcome."

Ms. Davis had no plans of getting off the bus at any of its stops at the center. She was passing through. That a public bus happened to cross a federal installation was, to her way of thinking, a mere happenstance. Early in her career as a public transit rider, she complied.

In the coming days, Ms. Davis began to feel as if her morning and evening bus rides were beginning to pass not through a federal office complex, but 1975 Argentina. The arbitrariness of things bothered her, too.

"It seemed to be subjective. A girl told me one day she was on there and she didn't have her ID and there were three kids on there and they made them get off and let her stay on. It seemed kind of subjective," she said.

For a few weeks she simply told the guards she didn't have any identification with her. "Then, on a Friday, the guard said 'You've been riding this bus long enough. You know you're supposed to have identification and if you don't have identification next time you come through here, you'll have to get off the bus.' "


So far no word on if and how the policy will change, I'll update if I find anything more precise on that aspect of it.

This article from Mike Littwin at the Rocky Mountain News is another good one if you are looking for information on the original incident with Deborah Davis.....

1 comment:

Hooda Thunkit (Dave Zawodny) said...

Surely the fact that the bus driver knows that the bus is only passing through and that she always gets off at the same stop should be enough for any reasonable person to leave her alone.

Sounds to me loke somebody is flexing their "brass" unduly...